Two Brothers Pizza

Discover delicious Italian favorites at Two Brothers Pizza in Cairo, NY. Enjoy large pies, hearty subs, garlic knots, and classic dishes like eggplant parm, chicken parm, spaghetti and meatballs, and more. Call us at +1 518-622-8284!

Welcome to Two Brothers Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Two Brothers Pizza
Two Brothers Pizza
Two Brothers Pizza
Two Brothers Pizza

Two Brothers Pizza combines vibrant flavors with a welcoming atmosphere. Located at 55 Co Rd 84, Cairo, NY, this lively spot caters to locals and visitors alike. The aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air, drawing diners in. With an array of Italian dishes available, the menu features something for everyone. Highlights include the beloved eggplant parmesan and their large, comforting pies. On a sunny day, the restaurant buzzes with laughter and the sound of clinking glasses, creating an inviting vibe that makes dining here feel like family. Stop by for a quick bite or settle in for a delightful meal with friends and family.

Location & Contact

Address

55 Co Rd 84, Cairo, NY 12413, United States

Phone

+1 518-622-8284

About

Two Brothers Pizza
Two Brothers Pizza
Two Brothers Pizza
Two Brothers Pizza

Opened with a mission to bring quality Italian comfort food to Cairo, Two Brothers Pizza has become a cornerstone of the community. The restaurant reflects the passion of its founders who aim to provide not just meals but memorable dining experiences. Guests love the hearty portions, and signature dishes like chicken Parmesan and spaghetti with meatballs ensure patrons leave satisfied.

The menu accommodates various tastes and dietary needs, showcasing a mix of classic and innovative dishes. For instance, the Philly Cheesesteak pizza pairs unexpected flavors and has become a local favorite. Visitors frequently rave about the warmth of the service, building a family-like bond that makes them feel at home. The restaurant thrives on its lively atmosphere, especially during peak hours of the week.

Locals gather on Friday nights to share laughter and enjoy delicious pies, making it a hub of community connection. The staff prides itself on consistent quality, and every visit feels welcoming. Furthermore, with its commitment to using fresh ingredients, each pizza and plate delivers authentic flavor that reminds diners of Italy. Two Brothers Pizza focuses on customer satisfaction, creating a place where every meal becomes a reason to return.

Work Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-7 PM
  • Monday11 AM-8 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-7 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-8 PM

Two Brothers Pizza stands out with its extensive menu, offering over 107 dishes. From specialty pizzas like the Old Fashioned Sicilian Style Grandma Pizza to hearty pasta entrées such as lasagna, there’s a culinary delight for every craving. Popular appetizers like buffalo wings and garlic knots complement the strong menu. Known for generous portions, it’s no surprise that Friday evenings see the place packed to capacity.

When lunch rolls around, expect a friendly rush, especially on Fridays when patrons flock to savor delicious food. Additionally, there’s a valuable variety of options, including gluten-free pizzas and fresh wraps, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a meal without feeling left out. The convenient location makes it easy to swing by and grab a bite after a day of exploring Cairo.

Two Brothers Pizza

The exterior of Two Brothers Pizza exudes charm with its rustic brick façade. Guests approach the entrance with anticipation of the cozy ambiance inside. Outdoor seating invites patrons to enjoy warm summer evenings while feasting on their favorite dishes and soaking in the vibrant community atmosphere. The colorful signage enhances the inviting nature of the space, often attracting a joyful crowd. Locals frequently gather outside to share stories or enjoy a slice, adding to the friendly vibe that makes this location a staple in Cairo.

Customer Reviews

Very delicious & filling pizza and more. Super friendly service and they're available for delivery or dine in. Thanks for the pizza!

M
Michael R.

Calzones are delicious, pick your favorite toppings for inside, just a note the ones in photos are smalls! They are stuffed and filling, so order accordingly! Delicious to the last bite! Pizzas being brought out around us looked amazing!

S
Stephanie C.

My friend told me about this place so I went ,I had a good meal, I did the Monday buffet. Can't beat the price, and most importantly I like the sauce. It had chunks of onion with fresh basil leaves. Sometimes simple foods are the best foods.The Eggplant parm had plenty of mozzarella, the vodka sauce was sweet with slices of chicken breasts. There was more choices included and all were good. I would go back. Neighborhood pizzeria had many local patrons coming from work and taking home what they wanted. You could tell they were repeat customers which is a compliment to the business. You would not believe this but before we left they gave us a doggy bag with 2 more dinners. Life is good and this place is special!

M
Margaret D.

I love this restaurant so much. My family and I always go and the food has great prices and it's so good!

N
Natasha S.

Recently my husband and I stopped there for something light to eat. Ever feel like not cooking? This is the place to go for delicious Italian food. Picture in yiur mind yummy eggplant parm or lasagne or such large heroes of yiur choice that are so big yiu could take the other half to work with yiu. Prices are fantastic compared to others. When the slogan Size Matters in this restaurant it certainly does, as they serve you what you pay for with a big plus and low prices that fit most pocketbook or wallets. The establishment has gone thru new hands over the many years gone by and this is a big improvement. I used to drive to catskill for delicious pizza, not anymore. Only a hop and a skip from my house. And it's great for Seniors pocketbooks. Stop in, you'll be glad you did. As a Google reviewer I approve of this restaurant. OK here's something New introducing soon the Senior Menu featuring meals for 7.95 soon. On all entre's. For us Seniors who deserve it. Tonight I had eggplant parm dinner! Salad, bread and butter spaghetti and eggplant for 13.50. Hubby had spaghetti and meatballs. My bill came to 31.76 includes tax and dessert. SENIORS THIS IS FOR US 65 OR OLDER. SEE YOU THERE. I recommend them highly. AAA+++

M
Martha I.

I love this place! When Brian's cooking everything comes out perfect to or better than perfect. Not to say when the other guys cooked it isn't perfect. But Brian is the best. There's always a healthy amount of toppings when ordered, the Pizza is never Burnt, or under cooked. That being said I do miss one amazing thing, when they first opened they had a family-size calzone it was absolutely amazing. I really do hope they bring it back. Check out this place on Mondays and Tuesdays between 5 and 8 I think, he usually has an all-you-can-eat buffet, I think the best menu I had in there was any pizza slices you wanted Buffalo macaroni and cheese perfectly cooked beef slices in gravy and spaghetti and meatballs. It's a small buffet but it's delicious. Usually consisting of four five items on the menu. Not bad for 12 bucks... My family two kids and a wife eat there often and we order out to our job frequently. Stop by look for Brian, tell him cowboy sent you!

S
Shawn K.